Renting vs buying is a long-standing debate amongst Canadians. And if we're being honest, it's not really an easy answer. There are a lot of factors that need to be considered when it comes to renting or buying a home.
If you're thinking about entering the real estate market, but aren't sure whether or not buying a house or renting a home is better for your financial situation and lifestyle, stick around as the team from BrokerLink dives further into this topic below.
Is it cheaper to rent or buy a house with a monthly mortgage in Canada?
It depends on where you want to live and the type of property you're looking at renting or buying. Because mortgage rates and the cost of housing have increased significantly over the past couple of years, both mortgages and monthly rent payments can be seen as substantial.
Ultimately, whether it's cheaper for you to rent or buy a house in Canada depends on individual circumstances, your finances, lifestyle preferences, and the housing market. Remember that it's absolutely essential that you carefully evaluate these factors and conduct an analysis of your overall short and long term goals.
You may also want to consult with a financial advisor who can help you with the overall decision-making process.
Is owning a home always better than renting?
Not necessarily. It really depends on the person, their situation, and preferred lifestyle. Let's dive into this in a bit more detail:
- First off, renting offers you a lower cost upfront and pretty predictable expenses month to month, compared to homeowners who have to deal with maintenance, repairs, their mortgage, taxes, and more. This reduced responsibility can reduce a tenant's overall stress levels and overall time commitments.
- Furthermore, when the housing market is doing poorly and home prices have skyrocketed, renting is often more accessible to many Canadians than home ownership. At the same time, for those looking to have a more flexible lifestyle where they can live in different spaces, more expensive neighbourhoods, urban locations, and other spots without having to sell a property beforehand, renting offers the ability to pick up and move whenever you feel like it.
While owning your own home in Canada offers benefits such as equity building and a sense of stability, renting can be a great option for those who are open to a more adaptable living arrangement. Ultimately, whether you choose to own or rent a home really comes down to your personal finances, lifestyle, and other factors.
Benefits of owning your own house in Canada
Homeownership comes with numerous benefits in Canada. If you're unsure whether buying a house is right for you, take a look at why it's a good investment for many Canadians:
Financial benefits
Homeownership provides several financial benefits, such as:
Building equity
One of the best aspects of buying a home is that each monthly mortgage payment you make increases your overall ownership of the property, also known as home equity. Over time, this will help you build equity. Unlike monthly rent payments, which give you no money in return, mortgage payments will contribute to your long-term financial circumstances, giving you more freedom.
Property appreciation
Property appreciation means that over time, as home prices across Canadian cities increase, the property value of your house can increase significantly. For example, let's say you purchase a home for $500,000 and decide to sell the property ten years down the road. The home value now is $850,000, meaning you made an additional $350,000 just by owning and living in the home.
Fixed rate mortgage payment offers financial security
With a fixed-rate mortgage payment, your monthly costs will stay the same for the entire duration of your mortgage. This offers peace of mind and protection from having to pay more money if interest rates also increase or if your landlord decides they want to increase your monthly rent payment.
Offers investment opportunities
If your finances enable you to do so, entering the real estate market and purchasing a secondary property can be a great investment that provides you with disposable income, should you rent it out to tenants. Passive income like this is a great way to save for the future.
Personal benefits
Homeownership also provides numerous personal benefits, such as:
Freedom over your living space
Being a homeowner gives you the freedom to decorate and renovate your property as you wish depending on your personal preferences and lifestyle, which many homeowners can appreciate. In contrast, when renting, you're typically not able to make any changes to the interior of your rental home beyond hanging paintings on the walls.
Privacy
Owning a home offers more privacy than renting. If you're in a single-family property, you won't have to share walls, ceilings, or common areas with your neighbours.
What are the downsides of owning a home in Canada?
Like any investment, there are some aspects to buying a house that some people consider to be a downside. Take a closer look:
Financial disadvantages
Homeownership in Canada comes with the following financial drawbacks:
A substantial financial commitment
Buying a home in Canada requires a significant upfront investment. This includes a down payment, closing costs to real estate agents, and other fees that can be incredibly costly. Furthermore, you'll be responsible for paying property taxes each year, depending on the appraised value of your home.
Further, whether you like it or not, maintenance costs are entirely your responsibility on top of your mortgage payments. And if you don't have a fixed mortgage payment, your low interest rates could skyrocket with little to no notice, leaving you number crunching on how to make up your house payments to your lender each month.
Property value can decrease over time
Depending on where you live, the value of your home and the property it sits on, there is a chance that it depreciates over time, meaning you will lose money in your investment.
Missed mortgage payments can affect your credit
Missing your monthly mortgage payments can negatively impact your overall credit score, unlike renting, which does not affect your credit score at all.
Long-term commitment
Additonal challenges of homeownership in Canada:
Challenges selling your home
Putting your house on the housing market and actually having to sell it to other homeowners can be a long process from start to finish, giving you less flexibility in the event your personal situation changes. It can also cost you a lot of time and money in terms of legal fees, closing costs, staging, and more.
Changes in the real estate market
The real estate market can be unpredictable. This means that if you need to sell your home right away, you could be selling at a time when selling high and buying low isn't possible, causing you to lose money, which is likely unrecoverable costs. Not to mention the added stress this can add to your personal life.
If you're ready to take the leap into homeownership, reach out to BrokerLink today. Let us help you find the perfect insurance coverage for your home. Get a quote now to get started!
Get a home insurance quote
What are the benefits of renting in Canada?
For the average Canadian, renting versus buying offers Canadians the preferred living choice. Here are some benefits of renting:
Financial advantages
Renting in Canada offers several financial advantages, including:
Lower costs
Renting a home from a landlord is a smaller upfront investment than actually paying for a home. In most cases, your down payment on the rental property is a security deposit and the first month's rent. Whereas when you buy a home, you will need to put a minimum of 5% down on the total cost of the property.
No Property Tax
As a renter in Canada, you are not responsible for paying property tax on the rental property you live in. Tax is to be paid by the landlord who owns the property. This can save you a significant amount of money, especially if you're renting a home that has a high property value.
Lower Maintenance Costs
Renting can be a more affordable option for most as any regular upkeep is generally covered by the landlord, which offers some serious appeal to individuals who don't want to pay for these types of expenses.
No financial risk
Renting a home means that you don't have to worry about whether there are any fluctuations in the real estate market or not. This means you can rest assured knowing that because you didn't invest in the rental home, you won't face the risk of depreciation.
Flexibility and freedom
Here's a closer look at the added advantages of flexibility and freedom when renting in Canada:
Can easily relocate
Renting a home rather than owning one offers you greater flexibility to move around whenever you feel like a change of scenery. Lease agreements tend to be one-year commitments. Once the year is up, most lease agreements go from month to month. Depending on the rental property, you might also be able to do a shorter lease term, such as six months or less.
Ultimately, this will allow you to relocate for work, travel, or a change in lifestyle without having to worry about putting your house up for sale, which makes more sense for most Canadians not tied down to one place.
Not a long-term commitment
As we said, renting is less of a commitment than owning a home. Enabling you to quickly change your circumstances if you need to.
You can live where you want
Paying rent empowers you to live wherever you want, whether it be in Canada or another country, whenever you feel like it. It could also allow you to live in neighbourhoods that are more expensive without actually having to pay the mortgage.
Convenience
Why convenience is another major benefit of renting in Canada:
Less responsibility overall
Renting vs buying really shifts the responsibility of property management and upkeep to the landlord or management company if you live in a condo or apartment building. This really appeals to people who do not want to be involved with the decision making of taking care of a property themselves.
Shared amenities
If you live in a condo building, your condo fees will go to shared amenities, which can really elevate your experience. Whether it be swimming pools, indoor gyms, sports courts, or a hangout room, renting means enjoying your building and meeting new people who also live on the property.
The downside of renting a home
So, what exactly are the downsides of renting versus buying a house in Canada? Take a closer look at some potential drawbacks below:
Financial disadvantages
Renting a home can be financially unfavorable for the following reasons:
Can't build equity
Unlike having a mortgage, renting a property does not help build equity. This means that you could be missing out on wealth opportunities and long-term financial stability. It also provides zero return over time.
Rent payments can increase
Unlike a fixed mortgage, your landlord can increase your rent when they like, for example, when your lease is over or in accordance with market prices in your area. This gives you less control of your finances.
Lack of property control
Lack of property control is another disadvantage of renting a home in Canada, and here's why:
Minimal personalizations
Renters can also be limited in terms of their overall ability to personalize or decorate their living space. Landlords can also impose restrictions on modifications and renovations to the interior of your rental home.
Additionally, many rental properties have restrictions or additional fees for pets, which can significantly limit your options and add housing costs to your situation.
When to rent in Canada instead of buy
Homeownership is not for everyone, and it's important to remember that it's completely okay. So, when exactly should you consider renting instead of buying? Here are some scenarios to think about:
You don't see yourself settling down any time soon
Owning a home is a long-term investment and commitment. If you still want to see the world, explore new job opportunities, or are not really sure what your next move is, renting really allows you that flexibility of not having to know what the future holds.
You aren't able to afford it
The minimum down payment on a property is 5%. If you are unable to afford the payment and a mortgage each month comfortably, rent will be substantially more affordable for you for a few years until you are able to show the bank that a mortgage is viable.
Your employment situation is up in the air
If you bounce from job to job, are a temporary employee, or are on contract, you may have a harder time being approved for a loan, given that lenders tend to see this as being high risk. In this case, stick with rent for the time being.
If you believe renting is the right choice for you, contact BrokerLink today. Our brokers can assist you in finding the perfect tenant policy to suit your needs.
Get a tenant insurance quote
When to buy instead of rent in Canada
In contrast, owning a home is a goal that a lot of Canadians have. You may be ready to own your own property if:
You're ready to settle down
You want to settle down for the future and start a family in one location. You're also ready to take on the responsibility of taking care of an entire property.
You are financially ready
Not everyone will be approved for a mortgage. You need savings, a steady job, and a good credit score to be able to take out a loan from the bank or credit lender.
You have a steady job
You've got a full-time, steady job that pays you well and offers you and your family financial stability.
Is it worth it to buy a house in Canada?
Whether or not it's worth it to buy a home in Canada really depends on numerous factors that need to be considered in depth before making any decisions. If you're unsure whether owning a home is an investment you want to make, consider the following:
Affordability
Think about whether you are in the financial position to make a down payment on a property, make monthly mortgage payments, pay yearly property tax, pay home insurance, and pay ongoing maintenance costs throughout the year if you purchase a house.
Think about the investment at hand
Really consider whether the opportunity for property appreciation is available for the home you are looking at buying. You should also think about what your long-term goals are in terms of investing and your financial situation as a whole.
Take a look at the current real estate market
You should also take a look at the current housing market conditions. Is it a good time to buy? What are the housing prices like in the area you want to live in? What about the interest rates? Asking yourself these questions can help you determine whether right now is a good time to make an offer or whether waiting for a later date may be more favourable.
Stability in your lifestyle
Consider what kind of lifestyle you live. Are you someone who values long-term stability when it comes to your living situation? Or do you prefer the flexibility and ability to move wherever you want that comes with renting.
Location, location, location
As you might already know, location in real estate is everything. Thinking about the location of the property you're looking at. How close is it to your job, transportation, schools, grocery stores, and other amenities? Would living there make your life more efficient?
Rental rates in your area
If you are still on the fence about whether or not you should buy or rent a home, take a look at the rental prices in your area. Are the rates something you can afford? Thinking about whether you want to pay someone else's mortgage instead of potentially paying your own.
Personalization of your living space
Living in a space you feel comfortable in and can make your home can really improve your quality of life. Are you interested in customizing and personalizing your living space? Or are you okay with living under the conditions that your landlord has set for the property?
Your financial goals
Think about your financial goals in depth. This should include things like accumulating weather, when you want to retire, and your overall financial health at the moment.
Your household
You need to also think about what kind of future you want. Would you like to live alone? With a roommate? Or are you someone who wants to settle down and have a family?
The financial risks
Look at the financial risks associated with owning a home. Are you prepared to pay for unexpected repairs and maintenance? What about if interest rates increase? Could you afford the increase each month?
Overall responsibility
Think about how much time and effort you want to put into buying and maintaining a home over the long run. Are you okay with the associated ownership expenses? Or would you prefer to have someone else take responsibility for the property you live in?
Owning a home is a big investment and decision. Make sure that you carefully consider the pros and cons of each type of living situation before making a choice for yourself. By considering the questions listed above, you should have more clarity moving forward!
Are there more renters or homeowners in Canada?
No, in Canada, there are more homeowners than renters. As of 2023, renters made up approximately one-third of the Canadian population or approximately 5 million households. That said, due to changes in the housing markets and high interest rates, renting has grown in popularity, especially in urban areas where housing costs continue to increase.
Purchase renters and home insurance with BrokerLink today!
Whether you rent or buy your home in Canada, having insurance is essential to protecting your personal belongings and finances.
At BrokerLink, we work closely with customers to ensure they get the right insurance coverage at an affordable price based on their unique needs. With locations across Canada, BrokerLink is here to make your insurance experience as stress-free and as seamless as possible.
If we're located in your neighbourhood, don't hesitate to come into one of our offices to work with an experienced broker from our team in person. If you can't make it in, you can also contact us over the phone during regular business hours, or use our free online quote tool to get competitive insurance quotes from the comfort of your own home.
[phone]
